By Jason Fletcher, FAITD
Feedback is essential for effective learning and development. It shows us whether our training is relevant, engaging, and genuinely making a difference. Many feedback and evaluation models are built for internal learning and development teams, making it difficult for external training providers to use them to collect feedback and data from a variety of clients.
This challenge inspired me to create the POPULAR model – a practical framework designed to measure the quality and impact of learning products while strengthening relationships with customers and learners.
Classic evaluation approaches like the Kirkpatrick Model and Phillips ROI Methodology remain useful, but they assume you have ready access to learners and their workplaces for extended follow-up. For an external training provider working with multiple organisations, that’s often not practical.
In response, I created a framework that is comprehensive and adaptable, capable of capturing feedback at various stages of the learner journey, and relevant to both our learning design team and our clients.
The POPULAR model combines well-known evaluation principles with a lens tailored for external providers. The acronym stands for:
Each element can be assessed through targeted questions. For example:
One advantage of the POPULAR model is its flexibility. Feedback can be collected before, during and after training, depending on the question. Tools might include surveys, polls, interviews, phone calls, or focus groups, and the resulting data can feed directly into product improvement and marketing.
In my implementation of the model, I focused on:
The model has proven to be successful, with actionable data collected that has informed the continuous improvement of training products, and delighted customers.
The POPULAR model provides a richer, more nuanced view of training effectiveness than a single end-of-course survey. It captures the whole learner journey, from first contact to post- training reflection, giving providers actionable insights to improve both learning outcomes and the customer experience.
For trainers, it’s an adaptable checklist to ensure no part of the learner experience is overlooked. For clients, it offers transparent evidence of training impact. And for learners, it’s an opportunity to actively participate in shaping their personal learning journey.
As implementation continues, my goal is to build a longitudinal dataset that monitors trends, benchmarks across programs, and answers the ultimate question: Are these courses POPULAR?
AITD Mentoring Program: Connect with experienced L&D professionals, gain guidance, share insights and grow your career. Find out more.
Why not try one of AITD's courses:
Neuroscience for Learning Design and Delivery: This program provides essential knowledge of the brain’s role in learning and offers a strong practical focus to translate the latest neuroscience into the design and delivery of effective learning experiences. Register now.
Measuring Learning Impact & Design for ROI: Go beyond smile sheets. Learn to evaluate learning and measure training ROI: design for impact, measure what matters and tell the story your stakeholders need to hear. Register now.
Needs Analysis: Are training programs always the best solution to an organisational problem? Analysing needs and then implementing practical evaluations are the bookends around the instructional design process. When implemented properly, they have the potential to shape processes, improve the quality of learning transfer methods and measure actual performance results. If you’re ready to become a performance consultant and trusted advisor, then this course is for you. Register now.
Jason Fletcher is an AITD Fellow and is Education Manager at Engineering Education Australia, where he leads the design, development and evaluation of award-winning learning products for engineers and related professionals. Contact: https://www.linkedin.com/in/1jasonfletcher/